Genetic Privacy

Have you ever made a discreet visit to the doctor without telling your family? The diagnosis of a family member with certain conditions could imply risks to your health. But it’s their right to withhold the information from you. Where are the lines drawn on the contentious issue of genetic privacy?
Your Genetic Privacy
You wouldn’t tell everyone you know every time you visit the doctor. But when it becomes more serious do you have a responsibility to share personal medical information? And conversely, do you have a right to access the medical history of your ancestors?Genetic privacy comes into play in the management and distribution of private medical information. This information is tugged in two directions by conflicting interests: one, the interest of the patient whose diagnosis should be kept confidential (patient/doctor confidentiality) and two, the interest of the potential patient (a family member) who could be taking preventative measures in view of the first patient’s diagnosis.
Many medical conditions are hereditary, and there are preventative measures that relatives are often advised to take. But can a doctor break the patient confidentiality bond?
Privacy in Practice
The Department of Health takes a firm stance on patient privacy. Medical professionals will always put the patient first, respecting their right to privacy. If you wish to keep your condition secret from family members, you have every right to do so. If you don’t want your medical information used for healthcare research, or even passed on to other professionals, your wishes will be respected.What are the exceptions? The Department of Health requires that the disclosure of medical information, whether the patient is dead or alive, meets the requirements of the Data Protection Act. Disclosure is only permitted when:
- There are reasonable grounds (to protect the patient, their family, or community)
- It is considered democratically necessary (particularly where it might affect others)
- It is proportionate to the need.
The British Medical Journal has debated the question of patient privacy. Taking the example of a young man who, diagnosed with a genetic disease, decided not to tell his two siblings, the Journal asked whether a doctor’s responsibility to the patient should always comes first. The doctor has three options: to remain silent, respecting his patient’s privacy; to try to persuade the patient to disclose his diagnosis; or to inform the family members. Under the Data Protection Act, health professional should always opt for the first choice. But is this the most ethical decision?
There are certainly grounds for reassessment of the Data Protection Act, which the BMJ supposes will come under review in the next few years – particularly as genetic testing becomes the norm. The American Society of Human Genetics already recommends that doctors should be permitted to pass on genetic information to family members where a patient refuses to do so.
Re: Does Neighbour's Camera Contravene Privacy Rights?
just walked down my street and 2 doors opposite side i felt i was being watched i noticed a camera, on…
Re: Your Privacy Rights at Work
My manager demanded an employee show them her private Facebook messages between her and other colleagues and as she is not happy we…
Re: What Are Your Rights Regarding Email Privacy In The Workplace?
New girl started on monday on Tuesday I was asked to train her I have done this all…
Re: Employee Surveillance
My Dental practice has a camera fitted in the changing room and this make me feel very uncomfortable, my employer said that the camera…
Re: Can I Use CCTV to Record Meetings in my Home?
Hi. I am having a serious problem with neighbours opposite my house. They have been threatening and abusive…
Re: Does Neighbour's Camera Contravene Privacy Rights?
My neighbour has recently put cameras on his house, one of the cameras looks like is pointing at my…
Re: Your Medical Records
Hi, I called my doctors to make an appointment in which they told me I am no longer registered there. I had no idea why and then they told…
Re: Do They Have the Right to Use My Photo on Website?
Hi, my previous employer has posted a promotional video which includes full images, including face.…
Re: Your Privacy Rights at Work
my employer has requested we download a app onto are own personal phone which we have discovered it has a tracking device on it.…
Re: Do They Have the Right to Use My Photo on Website?
Hi, I have emailed my previous for them to take down a video of me on there web page and they refused…