Am I Being Watched?
Employers are increasingly turning to surveillance to keep an eye on staff. Concerned about productivity and efficiency, big companies are using highly invasive techniques to monitor their teams. And even if you do no wrong, working in a company which uses these methods can put you at a disadvantage. Growing evidence shows that surveillance and monitoring causes relationships between an employer and employees to disintegrate: an insecure, nervous workforce is the price to pay for picking off the time-wasters.
However, many employers have good cause to monitor premises using a video recorder or similar. Petrol stations and customer care units, often targeted by fraudsters or perpetrators of abuse, are commonly filmed – to protect staff as much as spy on them.
Image and Photo Use Rights Checker (UK)
Someone has used your photo (or your child's) on a website, social media or marketing and you are not sure what your rights are. Answer a few questions and we will explain the position and what to do.
Try our Image and Photo Use Rights Checker (UK) free, here on this site →The History of Employee Surveillance
A number of high-profile surveillance cases have been in the news. BT’s infamous ‘Project Orwell’ was designed to monitor employees in and out of work, ensuring sick days and extended leave were justified. CCTV was supplemented by a squad of private detectives who followed employees home, taking secret photographs. Naturally, BT was severely lambasted for this project.
The line between acceptable and unacceptable surveillance is far from clear. For instance, an employee of Scottish Water lost a court case after he was fired for faking his time-sheets. The company had obtained secret video footage which proved that he wasn’t working the hours he claimed. Although the recording of this footage wasn’t in line with the Human Rights Act, the court ruled that it was reasonably undertaken in the circumstances.
Then there was the council worker whose home was watched by private detectives – to make sure that her injuries were real. How did she sustain these injuries? She was attacked at work by a person who had previously made threats to the council. She won £20,000 compensation.
Hearing all the stories about CCTV being installed in locker and changing rooms, microphones in petrol stations and telephone tapping, you’d be forgiven for thinking that British employees have fewer rights than convicts. What does the Human Rights Act say about all this?
Your situation may be slightly different. ask a question below ↓ and our editorial team will reply with our advice.
What are my Rights?
Your employer is perfectly entitled to record your actions and conversations. The only provison is that they must have good cause for doing so. Your employer must tell you that you are being videoed – secret cameras are not legal! They are not entitled to use the footage for any purpose that infringes your right to privacy. But they can use the footage to show that you are not carrying out your job properly – in other words, it could be used against you.
Concerned About Employee Surveillance?
If you believe that your employer is monitoring you without notification, take action.
- Ask your employer to make their surveillance policy clear. Precisely where, when and how are you being monitored? Your employer should provide a clear policy setting out the nature of any monitoring and (most importantly) exactly what is seen as a breach. If you aren’t aware of a policy, then ask – they must comply.
- If your employer denies monitoring you at work but you suspect foul play, you should contact your trade union. Cameras in changing rooms, toilet rooms and private offices are forbidden; cameras in a communal office or customer area are permitted, but you must be informed of their existence. If you aren’t a union member, call the Advisory, Conciliation and Arbitration Service (Acas).
I understood by reading the article above that it is illegal to have a camera in the changing room, could you please advise me what’s the law on this and which action can be taken as I feel very uncomfortable to go every day at work and get change knowing that he could possibly watch me while I get change . Many thanks
In the main office there is a large 50 inch display panel mounted on the wall which has a split-screen showing a live feed from the five cameras. This can be seen by everyone in that office not just the Manager.
I work in another office with around 10 people which has a camera recording us as we work. This means that everything we do can be seen by all the staff in the other office which I cannot see is acceptable.
Can you please advise teh law on this and what we can do as it is uncomfortable knowing you are being watched all day by everyone.
Thanks
0428543907
I have a question about a camera from next door.
Thanks
When calling the store manager was then under the impression that they were also privy to this information. Where do we go with this? My son has been made to look like the village idiot by people who are in a position of authority. The person who uploaded this was a manger!!
My employer has put cctv behind the bar and inside the social club I work at monitoring employees and customers as well the Secretary watches the club live from her house we now know this as she rang up and asked where one of the bar staff was as she couldn't see her on her screen at home is this legal
Can't talk anything private things.
If we do she asked us. We didn't know first why she knows.
We can't say anything.
Can they do spy our private.
We can say how bad my owner's are.
For Corporations, it's more about making a few extra pennies for the damn shareholders.
Either way this SHOULD be illegal unless to protect life (e.g. prisons)
Bosses can be unethical too, just as dirty and untrustworthy as employee's can be... Don't forget that!
I also cannot see any signs in the salon to say that there are cameras for your own safety (so the public are unaware) . Is this legal?
I emailed the video to my manager.
I would like to know of I can lose my nursing pin because of this issue.
Thank you
Any employer, employing such aides for surveillance should be familiar with human sensitivities, as well as human rights, per say, and should be aware that at some point that people outside their own world of Boss and ShopWorkers will find out about the surveillance, usually because it worries the shop-worker to the extent of informing customers their selves of their discomfort at working within the above 'conditions'.
Just to cite one situation, from my own experiences as a customer in such a position as above. (I), - spend a little extra time speaking to a shop-worker whom is in the middle ground, between acquaintance and friend, so to speak. I have recently discovered that the shop owner is using sound and visual recording methods, citing two main reasons to the part-time employees; 1). A very recent robbery after work hours. 2). Previous small scale fraud by previous employees.
In taking into account that one wish of the employer is that the shop door is left open so that it becomes a welcome gesture, so to speak, - which I do understand, this also affects the employees, whom get very cold, whilst at work! .... I have recently decided to limit the amount of time I spend, chatting to the employee because the employer, if so wishes, could warn 'said employee' that, "Too much time is used, chatting to customers!". The last thing I wish for is to get Any employee into trouble!
I would ask any employers out there to assess the plus's and minuses of this surveillance from the point of view (also) of the shop worker and the majority of the law abiding customers. To end, I will add that even before the employer resorted to this surveillance, - there was a very speedy 'turn-over rate'of different staff in the preceding year, obvious from public perception, because of the ever changing faces! Over indulgence with surveillance has effect and affect on many people, inside and outside of the shop, leading to decreased income within the shop and other variables outside the shop! This whole subject would not be such an issue if the employer used their empathy and skill to properly assess potential employees in the first instance. And here, I am only speaking of one hard working, honest and trustworthy employee. Best Regards To Those Willing To Prosper By Nurturing Basic Trust. 'Bad Brains' Steve.
the footage in question conveniently had no images just audio and a member of staff has sat through 4 hours of audio for no reason other than to hear what people are saying. he has then used this against some staff and resulted in a number of us being sacked..... the university are saying they arent interested how it was obtained and arent prepared to listen that it was recorded illegally, covertly to cause problems for individuals...
as anyone else had something llike this happen to them or have any advice for me??
Can an employer use dashcam footage as evidence against me without my autherisation?
My employer (who is not the owner) has recently connected the work cameras to her phone and she watches us constantly ...
She has started to text us when she is not in about what we are doing which i feel is not right . I have no problem with the camera in the front shop at all as i know it is for our best interest but watching us from home, i am not at all comfortable with .
Please can you give me some information as to my rights on this ???
The company's policy clearly states that CCTV can't be used in private areas. If that is the case can they still use the images against the individual as he's adamant that he never stole and that the locker that the items are missing from has always been a bit opened?
I dont get on with my manager and dont trust him whilst having a one to one meeting. He denies things that he has said and I can't prove it.
Am I legally allowed to take in and record our meetings without him knowing? It would only be saved for my information and to evidence anything that he may deny in the future.
That has been recorded to spy on a nother member of staff, with out permision from the owner
has said its to keep an eye on people not working,we have nothing in writing as yet.Some
cameras are on one to one and the rest in general distribution throughout the factory,even though there are parts of factory more dangerous that is not covered on one to one basis
thank you
I believe this blanket statement to be untrue. If the employer has reasonable grounds to believe that a crime is being commited then covert recordings are legal but they must be proportionate.
This is also the case for any infringement that goes against what is in the public interest.
That is my understanding at least. Happy to be corrected.
My employer over the last couple of years has installed cctv all around the factory. We have never been officially told why it's there but if you ask you get told it's just for security & health & safety.
I know that it's also being used in disciplinary situations as well but like I say we've never officially been informed of this.
I have found out that it's been added to the works handbook that they can use it for that but once again we were never made aware of this.
Are they allowed to carry on like this?
On of my colleagues, who had nothing to do with argument came over to us and recorded the part of it.
Video recording was made without my consent and knowledge of it.
Following this event I was officially given an investigation for inapropriate behaviour related to the video as well.
I would like to know if such recording can be legally used as evidence. If not, is there any legislation governing it?
I would really appreciate any help.
Thank you.
Hard disc recoeder with an App that allows the manager to view the cameras in store remotely. After the first instance of the off site monitoring being discovered by myself and a member of staff, the response from the Manager was 'I don't have time to sit about watching the shop on cctv'. Since this time it has been a regular occurence for the phone to ring in the shop on the Managers days off and for myself to be told about some thing happening in the shop, something I'm not doing or some other issues that come to their mind as they're monitoring the shop. As a volunteer I feel that I don't have much come back with htis and I know the employees do NOT have any thing in their contracts regarding this. No one has been informed that they will be monitored in the volunteer application forms either. No Policy doument for cctv has been made available to us either. 1984 anyone?
is this illegal??
She hasn't told me or as any reason to do this ,and I feel she is breaking the law by doing this .
Thanks
I got first suspended and while i was on suspension the company used my pics for training other staff without my consent. Can they do that?
Please help me.
Got a problem with , the problem I have is it is fitted with a microfibres so it will
Pick up any in cab noise ie radio , fione calls , I wud like to no if this is legal
Or is it an infringement on my human rites ?
Ask Your Privacy a question
Ask our editorial team a question and we will reply with our advice. Tell us as much about your situation as you can: the more detail you give, the more useful our answer can be.
You do not need to use your real name. Please do not include your full address, phone number, email address, or the names of other people. We may edit or remove identifying details for privacy and legal reasons.
Comments are moderated before publication.